The Delicate Art of Managing Performance
February 11, 2018
-Karthik Gurumurthy
Meet Priya, a seasoned manager who learned some of the hardest lessons about leading teams through difficult transitions. She remembered a particularly challenging situation with David, a long-time employee whose performance had gradually fallen behind the company's evolving needs.
"It's never just about the numbers," Priya would often say, reflecting on her experiences. She understood that behind every performance issue was a human story. Sometimes the problem wasn't the person at all - it could be a poorly designed role, a skills mismatch, or unclear expectations. Like a detective, she learned to look beyond the obvious, asking herself: "Is this truly a performance issue, or have we set someone up to fail?"
Priya had seen too many managers fall into what she called the "avoidance trap" - postponing difficult conversations until it was too late. She remembered one colleague confessing, "I wish I'd faced these issues quicker. Everyone would have been better off."
The most challenging cases, she found, weren't the obvious performance failures but the "good but not good enough" situations. These were loyal employees who had performed adequately for years but couldn't keep pace with the organization's growing ambitions.
When it came to terminations, Priya developed a compassionate yet professional approach. She never demonized employees or let her personal discomfort cloud her judgment. "Treating people with dignity," she would say, "isn't just about what you do, but how you do it."
Her most important lesson? The best way to handle performance issues was to prevent them through careful hiring. "Nothing you do will be more important than finding the right people," became her mantra. She learned that the right person wasn't just someone talented, but someone who aligned with the team's purpose, values, and ways of working.
This story taught her that effective leadership requires both strength and compassion - the wisdom to make tough decisions while preserving human dignity throughout the process.
Comments